Loading...

Dr Adrian Davis

Top line: Victim blaming in child pedestrian injuries is a strategy which serves to maintain the economic interests of the dominant groups in society at the expense and suffering of children, particularly those from low income families.

Whilst cardiovascular disease and cancer are the major causes of death in adults, in childhood, motor traffic inflicted injuries, particularly as pedestrians, are the leading cause of death. For every death approximately ten children are seriously injured. Many of these suffer long term disability. Individualism – ie the responsibility of individuals to take preventive action – constitutes the ideological base of preventive policies. Strategies for the prevention of child pedestrian injuries are, for example, almost entirely aimed at improving child pedestrian behaviour, despite robust evidence that this is likely to be ineffective.

Roberts and Coggan analysed the processes involved in the aftermath of the death of a 10 year old girl walking home from school.1 This included the police officer‟s report from attendance at the crash scene. At this stage the officer coded his form as “Pedestrian: crossing road heedless of traffic, unattended child”. A week later an engineer from the local highways department attends the site and notes the likely average speed of the motor traffic and the mean traffic flow per minute. From this Roberts and Coggan note that “there was a mean traffic flow at the injury site of 877 vehicles per hour, approximately 15 vehicles every minute. Thus the mean time available for crossing, assuming a steady flow, would have been only four seconds. It is quite likely therefore, that running was a necessary prerequisite for road crossing rather than an indication of impulsiveness”.

The Coroner‟s Inquest comes next. The stated aims of which are to determine the „facts‟ surrounding the death, primarily for the purpose of reliable record keeping for the State. In considering the case the coroner observed that because of the widespread provision of traffic education in schools the type of erratic traffic behaviour displayed, would be unusual for a 10-year-old. He observed that children are repeatedly told “don‟t jaywalk, but (name) may have been doing a little bit of jaywalking”. The verdict returned by the coroner stated: “‟I find that (name) died at (place) accidentally, sustained when she ran out into the path of an approaching vehicle without checking that the road was clear of traffic.”

In this case, a choice was made between the two main contenders for individual responsibility, the driver and child victim. Since the driver‟s claim of traveling at 40 kph (within the 50 kph speed limit) was accepted, no negligence was attributed to the driver. That responsibility was located with the victim. Although walking out into the road clearly did result in this child‟s death and might appropriately be considered a cause, it was nevertheless only one of a number of causes. „Other causes of pedestrian injury which could equally have been chosen for consideration would include poverty, high traffic volumes and high vehicle speeds.‟ However, a drawback of the multi-causal approach to causes is that it allows some causes to be singled out for attention above others. This is a choice motivated by ideology in which threats to road transport infrastructure must be resisted in order to protect vested interests which rest on economic expansion.


1 Roberts, I., Coggan, C. 1994 Blaming children for child pedestrian injuries, Social Science & Medicine,38(5):749-753.

110: Blaming Children for Child Pedestrian Injuries Download pdf PDF approximately 99.11 K

Views sought on Temple Cloud Liveable Neighbourhoods scheme

Views sought on Temple Cloud Liveable Neighbourhoods scheme

Residents in Temple Cloud are being asked to share their views on proposals to reduce the speed of traffic through the village and encourage active travel.

North Somerset Council. How do you travel in North Somerset? Take our Transport and Travel Survey.

Chance to win £50 with North Somerset Council's 2025 Transport and Travel Survey

Chance to win £50 with North Somerset Council's 2025 Transport and Travel Survey

North Somerset Council is inviting everyone who lives, works, or studies in, or regularly visits the area to take part in a new Transport and Travel Survey this summer.

West to deliver new walking, wheeling and cycling routes, including a more active school run

West to deliver new walking, wheeling and cycling routes, including a more active school run

Helen Godwin, the new Mayor of the West of England, has today joined a coalition of eleven of England’s regional Mayors to sign up to an ambitious joint statement pledging to create a new national walking, wheeling and cycling network, enabling millions more happy, healthy and green journeys.

Final comments sought on Sydney Road through-traffic restriction

Final comments sought on Sydney Road through-traffic restriction

Bath & North East Somerset Council is proposing to make permanent a through traffic restriction in Sydney Road, Bath following a six-month experimental trial.

Whiteladies Road to close northbound for flood prevention works

Whiteladies Road to close northbound for flood prevention works

Construction work, to prevent flooding and improve walking and cycling routes on a stretch of Whiteladies Road between its junctions with Tyndalls Park Road/St Pauls Road and Queens Road, will start on Monday 14 July 2025.