Segmentation is increasingly recognised as an important tool in delivery of travel behaviour change away from car use. In simple terms, some individuals and groups are more amenable to travel behaviour change than others. Approaches to segmentation have been developed in transport planning from the 1970s. 1 Behaviour change has also been a major focus of health psychology and health promotion and segmentation has been applied through various models such as the Stages of Change model (Pre-contemplation; Contemplation; Preparation; Action; Maintenance). 2
An influential recent paper on segmentation by Anable3 identified six distinct psychographic groups, each with varying degrees of mode switching potential. Each group represents a unique combination of preferences, worldviews and attitudes, indicating that different groups need to be serviced in different ways to optimise the chance of influencing mode choice behaviour.
Group
Mode switching potential
Malcontented Motorists
High moral responsibility to reduce car use
Complacent car addicts
Do not see many problems with car use, nor point of reducing it
Die hard drivers
Lowest desire to reduce car use, highest psychological car dependency
Aspiring environmentalists
Feel the most responsible for environmental problems; don’t enjoy car use
Car-less crusaders
Similar to above, although have more romantic view of nature
Reluctant riders
Not particularly motivated by environmental issues
Malcontented motorists who currently exhibit high car use also demonstrate a relatively high intention to change. Anable concluded:
concentrating on those who already use alternative modes a little to use them more and those who express a willingness to reduce car use to start
small individual changes can have significant effects on total numbers of alternative mode users.
Malcontented motorists should respond to promotional messages which remind them of the frustrations encountered with current levels of congestion together with messages which reinforce their moral imperatives and potential relaxing qualities of public transport.
Hence, the segmentation approach illustrates that policy interventions need to be responsive to the different motivations and constraints of various groups (nb strong crossovers with Social Marketing).
A hard copy of this week’s paper will be on my desk for those wanting more details.
1 Heggie, I., 1977 Putting Behavior into Behavioral Models of Travel Choice, Transport Studies Unit Oxford University, TSU ref: 061.
2 Prochaska, J., Marcus, B. 1994 The transtheoretical model: Applications to exercise, in Dishman, R. (ed) Advances in exercise adherence, Champaign.
3 Anable, J. 2008 ‘Complacent Car Addicts’ or ‘Aspiring Environmentalists’? Identifying travel behaviour segments using attitude theory, Transport Policy, 12: 65-78.
Next steps for multi-million-pound transport schemes
Next steps for multi-million-pound transport schemes
Plans for the next steps to improve major transport routes in the city are set to be considered as part of the proposed multi-million pound investment in Bristol’s highways.
Brunel Way overnight closures coming up this month
Brunel Way overnight closures coming up this month
Avon Bridge on Brunel Way (A3029) is set to close overnight in alternate directions for ten nights in March, to allow the council to carry out essential maintenance work to replace an expansion joint that has failed.
Weston Bus Interchange improvements from Mon 10 April
Weston Bus Interchange improvements from Mon 10 April
Works to make a simple but effective change at Weston Interchange, allowing for more flexible and efficient bus movements, started on Monday 10 March for three weeks.
This package would start on 1 April 2025 and run until 31 March 2026. It would represent a £1.3 million investment from the Mayoral Combined Authority’s Bus Grant allocation and further funding from that of North Somerset Council: supporting more people to travel cheaply – or for free – and sustainably by public transport.