Loading...

Dr Adrian Davis

Top line: Switching from private motor transport to active travel or public transport is associated with a significant reduction in weight. In contrast, switching from active travel or public transport to private motor transport is associated with a significant weight increase.

Previous research has charted how a shift in travel mode away from active travel is strongly associated with weight gain.1 Evidence for a reverse effect, that is, a change in mode from private motorised transport to active travel has been weak due to the study design of most papers which limits the potential for drawing reliable causal inferences. A 2015 longitudinal study has used a nationally representative data set – the British Household Panel Survey (BHPS)2 – to examine the impact on Body Mass Index (BMI) of switching between private motor transport and active travel or public transport for the journey to work.3 Thus, this study was able to examine the effect both of a switch to active modes from private motor transport (3269) or to private motorised transport from active travel modes (787).

The researchers observed that switching from private motor transport to active travel or public transport was associated with a reduction in BMI, even in a relatively short-time period of under 2 years. This suggests that a shift in the proportion of commuters using more active modes of travel could contribute to efforts to reduce the population’s average BMI. Combined with other potential health, economic and environmental benefits associated with walking, cycling and public transport, these findings add to the case for interventions to promote the uptake of these more sustainable forms of transport. If large numbers of people could be enabled to take up active travel to work, for example through environmental and policy interventions in the transport and planning sectors, the benefits for population health may be larger than those of alternative interventions targeted at producing larger individual health benefits for relatively small numbers of people.

The finding that participants who switched to active travel were, on average, from lower income households, less likely to be educated to degree-level or higher and more likely to work part-time than other participants in the study could be indicative of the potential for interventions in the transport and planning sectors to support strategies to reduce health inequalities.

The significant association observed between change in BMI and switching from private motor transport to active travel or public transport supports the implications of existing studies showing that public transport users can achieve significant levels of physical activity when accessing stations or stops.4


1 See Essential Evidence issues 7 & 58 www.travelwest.info/evidence
2 The BHPS is a longitudinal study of private households in Great Britain that began in 1991/1992 as an annual survey of each adult member of a nationally representative sample of households. BHPS after 2008/2009 are encompassed in the new ‘Understanding Society’ survey, http://www.iser.essex.ac.uk/survey/bhps
3 Martin, A., Panter, J., Suhrcke, M., Ogilvie, D. 2015 Impact of changes in mode of travel to work on changes in body mass index: evidence from the British Household Panel Survey, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 0:1-9. doi:10.1136/jech-2014-205211
4 See Essential Evidence 28 www.travelwest.info/evidence

135: Impact of changes in mode of travel to work on changes in body weight Download pdf PDF approximately 163.5 K

Views sought on Temple Cloud Liveable Neighbourhoods scheme

Views sought on Temple Cloud Liveable Neighbourhoods scheme

Residents in Temple Cloud are being asked to share their views on proposals to reduce the speed of traffic through the village and encourage active travel.

North Somerset Council. How do you travel in North Somerset? Take our Transport and Travel Survey.

Chance to win £50 with North Somerset Council's 2025 Transport and Travel Survey

Chance to win £50 with North Somerset Council's 2025 Transport and Travel Survey

North Somerset Council is inviting everyone who lives, works, or studies in, or regularly visits the area to take part in a new Transport and Travel Survey this summer.

West to deliver new walking, wheeling and cycling routes, including a more active school run

West to deliver new walking, wheeling and cycling routes, including a more active school run

Helen Godwin, the new Mayor of the West of England, has today joined a coalition of eleven of England’s regional Mayors to sign up to an ambitious joint statement pledging to create a new national walking, wheeling and cycling network, enabling millions more happy, healthy and green journeys.

Final comments sought on Sydney Road through-traffic restriction

Final comments sought on Sydney Road through-traffic restriction

Bath & North East Somerset Council is proposing to make permanent a through traffic restriction in Sydney Road, Bath following a six-month experimental trial.

Whiteladies Road to close northbound for flood prevention works

Whiteladies Road to close northbound for flood prevention works

Construction work, to prevent flooding and improve walking and cycling routes on a stretch of Whiteladies Road between its junctions with Tyndalls Park Road/St Pauls Road and Queens Road, will start on Monday 14 July 2025.